Home News Local news CZM Approves Permit Modifications for Coral World Dolphin Attraction

CZM Approves Permit Modifications for Coral World Dolphin Attraction

4

Officials from Coral World Ocean Park received endorsement on several requests for reconsideration of special conditions on Thursday, paving the way for work to proceed on a dolphin exhibit at the popular marine theme park.

The Coastal Zone Management Board meeting was held in the conference room of the Department of Planning and Natural Resources on the second floor of the Cyril E. King airport and, because Thursday’s meeting was a decision meeting and not a public hearing, the public was invited to attend but the committee did not allow comments from those in attendance.

“We are very pleased with tonight’s decisions,” said Coral Word owner Trudi Prior following the announcement. “The Coastal Zone Management staff and committee listened and addressed each request in an equitable and fair manner.”

On March 26, 2013, the Division of CZM received correspondence from Coral World officials requesting the reconsideration of several special conditions pursuant to a major permit application that had previously been approved on Feb. 13 in a four-to-one vote.

The habitat structure planned by Coral World would provide a two-acre space supported by concrete pilings and stainless steel mesh that would serve as the pen’s walls. Plans also include a medical facility, a birthing and breeding area, in addition to a movable platform allowing visitors of all ages and disabilities the opportunity to interact with the mammals.

Coral World officials say the dolphin exhibit will draw an additional 25,000 to 35,000 visitor per year, add 20-25 new jobs at the park, and contribute more than $4 million to the territory’s economy.

While there were several special conditions attached to the permit by the CZM committee, park officials were most concerned with the following:
– That the park would be allowed to commence its interactive program with six dolphins for a three-year period during which water quality parameters would be recorded on a monthly basis before additional dolphins could be requested. The results of the water quality monitoring would then be submitted to the CZM committee in an annual report. Coral world officials argued successfully that water quality does not need to be monitored for three-year period in order to determine whether the dolphins are negatively impacting the area and that a three-year waiting period would further serve to inhibit the business model as it was originally proposed. An amendment was granted changing the study to a one-year monitoring period before requesting additional dolphins.
– That in accordance with the memorandum from the Division of Fish and Wildlife, the park will submit a strategic plan within 90 days to relocate the sea lion exhibit from their current holding pens to a permitted permanent facility and come into compliance with DFW issued permits. Stating that the original plans for a large-scale sea lion habitat had changed and that the original permit for a dolphin exhibit was now the main focus, the committee ruled that the permit was all encompassing and treated the water park as one existing facility. In their ruling, the committee did state that CZM staff had met as recently as April 12 with DFW and that there are no outstanding compliance issues with permits issued for the sea lions and, as such, conditions relating to permits for the sea lions can be removed.
– The final stipulation required by the original permit stated that Coral World would be required to apply for accreditation from the Alliance of Marine Parks and Aquariums within 90 days of the execution of the permit and submit evidence of such to the CZM committee. The park argues that the project still has to be approved by the Army Corps of Engineers as well as the U.S. Department of Agriculture along with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration who must also approve separate permits involving the importation of the dolphins. Allowing for the additional permits still remaining, the committee changed the timeframe required, giving Coral World 12 months to apply and that once membership had been granted that it be reported accordingly.

Other business that was approved Thursday was the modification of an existing major permit first granted to the West Indian Company Ltd. in 1989 and modified three additional times since calling for the installation of a pile supported mooring dolphin to the existing WICO dock structure, as well as a 120-foot walkway structure which will provide access from the new mooring dolphin to exiting dock.

“Other competing cruise ship stops such as Saint Marten are out ahead of us,” said Mark Sabino, WICO’s director of marine services. ”The region and the industry demand these changes.” The changes are in reference to the post-Panama Canal built cruise ships already scheduled to call on the territory in the next season. The new ships expected range in size from 950 to 1,150 feet in length. The installation of two new bollards, used to tie up the ships will be completed by July 30 while the deadline for the dock extension is slated for early November.

Also passed by the committee were CZM permit requests for assignment and transfer of major permits by RC St. Thomas LLC (f/k/a Cabrita Partners LLC) to Development Partners International LLC and the restructuring of the original permit that once included the development of timeshare properties to luxury condominiums. An extension was also granted to extend an existing permit to allow for the new direction the project has taken.

CZM Board members present at Thursday’s meeting were Peggy Simmonds, Winston Adams, Richard Brown, Karl Purcell and Chairman Austin Monsanto.

4 COMMENTS

  1. It is an absolute travesty that this Dolphin park is being allowed, at all, here in the Virgin Islands.

    This comes at a time many countries and nations are rallying to protect marine mammals in their waters by creating sanctuaries for them from the likes of Coral World and the marine entertainment businesses which perpetuates the trapping, culling and killing of Dolphins and the capture of those that are sold into an abject life of slavery. All for sake of money.
    Disgusting.

    I will never recommend anyone to go to Coral World, ever again, nor will I go. When you buy a ticket to these attractions you are perpetuating the demand for continuing captivity of these magnificent and intelligent marine mammals.

    The Humane Society International and the World Society for the Protection of Animals have stated that they believe that “the entire captive experience for marine mammals is so sterile and contrary to even the most basic elements of compassion and humanity that it should be rejected outright.”

    The more that people educate themselves and realize the truth about dolphinariums, the better. Don’t buy a ticket. Don’t support captivity.

  2. It is unenlightened people such as yourself that condemn these dolphins to the “captive experience that is so sterile and contrary to even the most basic elements of compassion and humanity that it should be rejected outright.”

    If you wish to educate yourself regarding dolphin exhibitions and the plight of dolphins, please read:
    http://www.humanesociety.org/assets/pdfs/marine_mammals/case_against_marine_captivity.pdf

    It is a 76 page detailed document titled “The Case Against Marine Mammals in Captivity” written by scientists and published by The Humane Society International and The World Society for the Protection of Animals.

    Please don’t support this continued abuse and cruelty of a free roaming, intelligent species that scientists now realize should be given personhood and are sentient beings that are self aware.
    You shall doom them when they deserve our protection.

  3. The ethics of keeping animals captive for entertainment purposes is hotly debated around the world, with some nations already banning the use of wild animals in zoos.

    However, the issue of keeping dolphins captive is particularly poignant since they are highly intelligent, emotional and sentient beings that are capable of great mental and physical suffering.

    “Dolphins are very smart. They’re the only wild animal I’m aware of that regularly rescues humans who are in trouble,” Ric O’Barry points out.

    “They grieve for their lost offspring and companions. They have even been seen asking for help from humans. All of this shows their incredible sense of compassion and understanding towards others, yet we show them none in return when we keep them captive.”

    These stances are supported by well-established indications that dolphin captivity is unethical and inflicts unnecessary suffering onto dolphins. Food deprivation, forced performances, and a complete lack of freedom contribute to significant stress and often premature death for captive individuals.

    “The global captivity industry depends on its customers not knowing the truth about what goes on behind the bright lights and sensationalism,” says O’Barry, referring to the illusions that captive facilities construct in order to mislead customers into believing that the dolphins are “happy.”

    Take the pledge: Don’t buy the ticket. Dolphins and Whales and other marine mammals do not belong in captivity.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here